News

Car ban is not the answer to deaths of young drivers

INFORM NOT REFORM: Former defensive driving instructor Carl Hillman said the solution to less road fatalities isn't bans, but education.
INFORM NOT REFORM: Former defensive driving instructor Carl Hillman said the solution to less road fatalities isn't bans, but education. Danielle Lowe

THE new year started with the death of two young men in a violent car crash in Ipswich.

It took the national Christmas holiday road toll to 43.

The accident spurred the city's mayor Paul Pisasale into action.

Cr Pisasale has called for a complete ban on young people driving high-performance vehicles.

But a former defensive driving instructor from Kingaroy is furious about the suggestion.

Instead, he said there needed to be urgent reform to the State Government's driver education program.

Carl Hillman was a defensive driving instructor for 12 years.

He said banning people from driving high-performance vehicles was the wrong idea.

"Education is absolutely the key to a lot of these road fatalities," he said.

"The current system gives them a license to go out and kill themselves and their friends because they have not been trained to drive a car properly.

"If we train our drivers on car control and the engineering of the car, then they have the correct basis on which they can act."

Mr Hill said major changes needed to be made to the state's Q-Safe practical driving test.

He said the test should incorporate defensive driving training, to help get the road toll down.

"Current tests and training do not put them into stressful situations," Mr Hill said.

"And when they come to one, they don't know what to do.

"The most dangerous thing people can do in life is drive a car.

"And if they don't understand what they're doing is life-threatening, these road accidents will continue."

Mr Hillman said lack of driver training on different types of vehicles was another major flaw of driver training tests.

"Most driving schools use little front-wheel drive cars and most parents have front-wheel driving cars," he said.

"Things like your steering, turning and braking all change when you drive different vehicles.

"And (this) is not being taught in the current system."

But Nanango driving instructor Andrew Cross did not agree with Mr Hill.

He said incorporating defensive driving into vehicle licence training and tests was unnecessary.

"The test is quite comprehensive in its current form," he said.

"For someone to need to use defensive driving manoeuvres, then there is a good chance they are driving over the speed limit or dealing with an illegal situation.

"It is incredibly difficult to get modern cars to slide, if you're driving the speed limit and driving to weather conditions."

Department of Transport and Main Roads statistics showed drivers aged 17-24 were at least 50% more likely than other motorists to be involved in a fatal road crash.

Before applying for a P1 licence, current learner drivers are required to pass a theory test.

They also need to show they have had 100 hours of supervised driving.

Alternatively, P1 licence applicants could have held a learner's permit for two years.

South Burnett

Topics:  accident, car, car crash, defensive driving, driver education, driving


Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Give your say at wind farm meeting

WINDFARMS: Power for the future or villains?

AGL to offer community chance to visit existing wind farms

Man hospitalised after lawn mower incident

A 15-year-old girl was taken to Kingaroy Hospital before being flown to Royal Brisbane and Women's Hospital.

A man in his 20s hospitalised with hand injury after mower incident

Bunya Mountains dusted white this morning

BUNYA MOUNTAINS: Mountains wake to white dusting.

Bunya Mountains dusted white

Latest deals and offers

BREAKING: Department confirms new case of black lung

Department of Natural Resources and Mines say it's the eighth case identified since May last year

Give your say at wind farm meeting

WINDFARMS: Power for the future or villains?

AGL to offer community chance to visit existing wind farms

Man hospitalised after lawn mower incident

A 15-year-old girl was taken to Kingaroy Hospital before being flown to Royal Brisbane and Women's Hospital.

A man in his 20s hospitalised with hand injury after mower incident

Bunya Mountains dusted white this morning

BUNYA MOUNTAINS: Mountains wake to white dusting.

Bunya Mountains dusted white

Early morning temperatures about to plummet

NEGATIVE TEMPERATURES: South Burnett heading into some cold weather.

Early morning temperatures about to plummet

Things to do in the South Burnett these school holidays

Octopus Hank (Ed O'Neill) and Dory (Ellen DeGeneres) in a scene from the movie Finding Dory.

Things to do in the South Burnett these school holidays

Burnett Heads housing development approved

COUNCIL APPROVED: A Burnett Heads housing development has been approved by Bundaberg Regional Council. Photo Contributed

Councillors approved the development seven votes to four

Three bedroom, 1100sqm block: Is this Qld's cheapest home?

BARGAIN BUY: Is this North Bundaberg property the cheapest home in Queensland?

Becoming a real estate mogul is all about risk and reward